Back to Insights

BUSINESS CASH FLOW & TAXES

Should I Pay Myself More or Leave Money in the Business?

Matt Hertig

Founder, Owner Wealth Partners

Author of Owning Differently

Owner pay is often set years ago, adjusted here and there, and rarely revisited. It covers the mortgage and the tuition, and whatever is left sits in the business. The question that matters rarely gets asked: is the way I take money out of this business building the wealth I want, or just covering this year?

You Are Being Paid for Two Different Things

Every owner-operator wears two hats, and each one earns something different:

Operator Pay

What it would cost to hire someone to do your job.

Owner Return

What the business earns for you as its owner, after the job is paid.

When the two blur together, owners tend to treat everything as salary for the work, or everything as money the business might need. Separating them makes the decision clearer.

Three Buckets, in Order

Instead of asking how much to take, sort the money into three buckets:

1. Pay the role

Set compensation for the work you do at a level that reflects the job, consistent with your entity structure and applicable tax rules.

2. Fund what the business genuinely needs

Reserves, committed obligations, and reinvestment that can justify its return.

3. Deploy the owner return on purpose

What remains is the return on your ownership. It can stay in the company, but only as a decision. It can also fund retirement contributions, personal liquidity, and investments you own outside the business.

Leaving money in the business is not a neutral choice. It is an investment decision in a single, illiquid asset.

How It Connects

Owner compensation can include salary and, where applicable, distributions. How you split them can affect payroll taxes, retirement plan contributions, business cash flow, and how much you can invest personally, all at once. What is appropriate depends on your entity structure, applicable tax rules, the needs of the business, its cash flow, and your goals. There is no single compensation approach that fits every entity type or every owner.

This is not about taking more out at the expense of the business. It is about funding the company and funding your future on purpose, in a proportion that fits your situation.

A Better Question to Ask

Instead of asking "Should I pay myself more?" ask: "After my role is paid and the business is funded, where should my owner return go to build the most wealth for me?"

Want to See How the Pieces Fit Together?

The Business Wealth Diagnostic helps identify where your business and personal wealth strategy are connected, where they are not, and what deserves attention first.

Business Wealth Review

The information provided is for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended as individualized investment, tax, legal, insurance, or financial advice. Strategies discussed may not be appropriate for every business or owner. Business owners should consult the appropriate financial, tax, legal, insurance, and other professional advisors regarding their individual circumstances.